
Biz Markie sits under a barber’s chainsaw in this 1991 ad for I Need a Haircut, and the single plugged across his cape turned out to be a prophecy: “What Comes Around Goes Around.”
One of the album’s 13 tracks, “Alone Again,” was built on Gilbert O’Sullivan’s 1972 ballad “Alone Again (Naturally),” using its music and three words of its lyric. Biz’s side knew it needed permission. According to the court record, they had contacted O’Sullivan and his brother, who was also his agent, to try to get a license before the album came out. The song went out anyway.
Thou shalt not steal
O’Sullivan sued. In December 1991, U.S. District Judge Kevin Thomas Duffy opened his ruling with four words: “Thou shalt not steal.” He dismissed the argument that sampling without clearance was common practice in the business, ordered the four-month-old album pulled from stores, and referred the case to the U.S. Attorney for possible criminal prosecution. No charges were ever filed, but Warner Bros. and Biz agreed to a substantial payment.
The ruling made sample clearance the rule in hip-hop and made dense, sample-heavy production expensive. Biz answered with a joke. His next album, in 1993, was titled All Samples Cleared!, and on the cover he played both the judge and the defendant. Current releases of I Need a Haircut leave out “Alone Again.”






Comments